Skip to content

A Brony Tale: An Unconventional Fandom Explored

Dive into the world of bronies with "A Brony Tale" – an enlightening exploration of unconventional fandom and evolving expressions of masculinity.

Keywords: Bronies, My Little Pony, Fandom, Gender Norms, Masculinity, Documentary. Three words: Unconventional, Enlightening, Respectful


"A Brony Tale" is a captivating documentary directed by Brent Hodge, released in 2014. It explores the world of "bronies," a subculture of adult male fans of the children's TV show "My Little Pony." In an era where fan culture and unconventional expressions of masculinity are gaining recognition, the relevance of this documentary is undeniable.


The documentary follows Ashleigh Ball, the voice behind "My Little Pony’s" characters Apple Jack and Rainbow Dash, as she dives into the world of bronies. The documentary unravels the complexities of this niche fandom, challenging stereotypes and perceptions about masculinity and fandom.

More Film Analysis


"A Brony Tale" adopts a participatory approach, as Ball interacts directly with bronies. The documentary is well-researched, offering an in-depth exploration of its subject. The presentation is engaging, often humorous, but always respectful.

Historical and Factual Context

"My Little Pony" is a popular children's show, first aired in the 1980s. The brony subculture emerged in the 2010s, primarily through online communities.

Key themes in the film

  • Questioning gender norms and societal expectations
  • The power of fandom and shared interests
  • Acceptance and understanding of unconventional hobbies

Film Comparisons

Unlike other fandom documentaries on iWonder, "A Brony Tale" focuses on a fandom considered unconventional due to gender and age expectations.

Noteworthy Moments

One profound revelation is when a military serviceman opens up about his love for "My Little Pony," challenging stereotypes about masculinity.


Critics have praised the documentary for its respectful and open-minded portrayal of the brony community.


"A Brony Tale" offers a fascinating glimpse into a misunderstood subculture, encouraging viewers to challenge their assumptions about gender norms and fandom. This documentary is particularly relevant for those interested in popular culture, gender studies, or fandom dynamics.

More film information:


  • IMDB score: 5.5/10
  • Rotten Tomatoes score: 67%



  • Ashleigh Ball: Voice actress for "My Little Pony" characters Apple Jack and Rainbow Dash



  • BronyCon: An annual fan convention for bronies

Key Questions raised by the film:

  1. How does "A Brony Tale" challenge gender norms and societal expectations?
  2. What makes the brony fandom unique?

I wonder what the film would be in another art form

Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
  1. If this film was a famous book, it would be "Fangirl" by Rainbow Rowell - both explore fandom culture in a respectful way.
  2. If it was a famous song, it would be "True Colors" by Cyndi Lauper - both celebrate individuality and acceptance.
  3. If it was a famous piece of art, it would be "The Persistence of Memory" by Salvador Dali - both challenge conventional perspectives.
  4. If it was a famous celebrity, it would be Keanu Reeves - both are beloved yet often misunderstood.
  5. If it was a colour, it would be rainbow - representing the diversity in the fandom.
  6. If it was a music style, it would be pop - fun, uplifting, and often underestimated in its depth.