Skip to content

Between Black and Blue: New York detectives convicted of murder

Between Black and Blue is a gripping true crime documentary that explores the controversial conviction of two NYC detectives for murder, their fight for justice, and the hunt for the truth.

Keywords: True Crime, Murder Investigation, New York City, Police Corruption, Conviction, Justice, 1970s, Innocence Project, Documentary Series. Three words: 'Intense', 'Revealing', 'Suspenseful'.


Between Black and Blue is a gripping 2020 documentary series that delves into the controversial story of two New York City detectives convicted of murder. The series follows their relentless fight to clear their names and the ongoing search for one of the confessed gunmen who might hold the key to the truth.


In the late 1970s, two NYPD detectives, Bob Davis and Mike Borrelli, were convicted of a murder they vehemently denied committing. The series explores the twists and turns of the case, documenting the detectives' struggle for justice while throwing light on the rampant corruption within the police department at the time. Through a combination of archival footage, interviews, and in-depth research, the series offers an unprecedented exploration of a complex and riveting true crime story.

More Film Analysis


Between Black and Blue stands out for its meticulous research and deep-dive exploration of the case. The series blends a narrative style, investigative journalism, and compelling storytelling to shed light on a fascinating and lesser-known chapter of NYC's crime history.

Historical and Factual Context

The series provides a rich historical context, painting a vivid picture of 1970s New York City and the rampant corruption within its police department. This context adds depth to the narrative and helps viewers understand the circumstances that led to the detectives' controversial conviction.

Key themes in the film

  • Fight for justice
  • Police corruption
  • Miscarriage of justice
  • Truth and redemption

Film Comparisons

Between Black and Blue can be compared to other true crime documentaries like Making a Murderer or The Jinx. However, it sets itself apart with its focus on the detectives' perspective and the historical context of 1970s NYC.

Noteworthy Moments

One significant moment in the series is when one of the confessed gunmen reiterates his confession, adding a new layer of complexity to the case.


Between Black and Blue has been well-received by audiences, with an impressive IMDB score of 8.2. Critics have praised its detailed exploration of the case and the historical context it provides.


Between Black and Blue is a must-watch for true crime enthusiasts and anyone interested in the complexities of justice and corruption within law enforcement. Its intriguing narrative and meticulous research make for a captivating viewing experience.

More film information:


  • IMDB score: 8.2
  • Awards and Festival summary: N/A



  • Bob Davis: One of the convicted detectives fighting to clear his name.
  • Mike Borrelli: The other convicted detective, who also maintains his innocence.



  • New York City, 1970s: The main setting of the documentary.

Key Questions Raised by the Film:

  1. What led to the conviction of the two detectives?
  2. How did corruption within the police department influence the case?
  3. What role might the confessed gunman play in uncovering the truth?

I wonder what the film would be in another art form

Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
  1. If this film was a famous book, it would be 'In Cold Blood' by Truman Capote, as it also explores a complex murder investigation.
  2. If this film was a famous song, it would be 'I Fought the Law' by The Clash, reflecting the detectives' struggle against a corrupt system.
  3. If this film was a famous piece of art, it would be 'Guernica' by Picasso, depicting chaos and injustice.
  4. If this film was a celebrity, it would be Robert De Niro, known for his roles in crime dramas.
  5. If this film was a color, it would be blue, symbolizing the police and their struggle for justice.
  6. If this film was a music style, it would be Blues, reflecting the melancholic struggle and desire for redemption.

Watch the documentary on iWonder:

Watch Between Black And Blue - Streaming Online | iwonder (Free Trial)
This true crime documentary series explores the extraordinary story of two NYC detectives who are convicted of the 1975 murder of a Denver businessman and their decades-long fight to clear their names.

Watch the trailer:

Peace officer

Watch Peace Officer - Streaming Online | iwonder (Free Trial)
The film is told through the story of a former sheriff who established his state’s first SWAT team only to see that same unit kill his son-in-law in a controversial standoff 30 years later. Driven by an obsession, he uses his own investigative skills to uncover the truth in this and other officer…

Betrayal at Attica

Watch Betrayal At Attica - Streaming Online | iwonder (Free Trial)
On September 13, 1971 the State of New York shot and killed 39 of its own citizens, injured hundreds more, and tortured the survivors. The plan to retake D Yard led to one of the bloodiest days in American history, and set the stage for the worst aspects of modern policing. Firebrand lawyer Elizabet…

Innocent on Death Row

Watch Innocent On Death Row - Streaming Online | iwonder (Free Trial)
Delve into the case of Clinton Young, who was charged with the murder of two men and sentenced to death, despite evidence of innocence and an unfair trial. Is the wrong man on death row?

Tales of the Grim Sleeper

Watch Tales Of The Grim Sleeper - Streaming Online | iwonder (Free Trial)
Lonnie Franklin Jr. was arrested in July 2010 after a 25-year killing spree in which it is thought he could have killed over 100 victims, potentially making him the most prolific serial killer in history. His arrest was not the product of detective work but completely accidental, the result of a com…