Skip to content

"A Closer Look at 'Murder in Melbourne'

'Murder in Melbourne' is an eye-opening examination of the tragic consequences of a failing parole system in Melbourne, Australia.

Keywords: Murder in Melbourne, parole system, justice, Australia, documentary, crime. Three words: 'Eye-opening', 'Disturbing', 'Unsettling'


'Murder in Melbourne', directed by Terry Carlyon and released in 2016, offers a deep dive into a series of tragic deaths in Melbourne, Australia, and the controversy surrounding the city's failing parole system.


This documentary delves into the harrowing stories of three women, whose lives were tragically cut short by men with violent histories. The film further scrutinizes the parole system, which allowed these dangerous individuals to roam free, leading to fatal consequences.

More Film Analysis


'Murder in Melbourne' is a stark, unflinching look at a flawed parole system, showcasing in-depth research and interviews with victims' families, legal experts, and law enforcement officers. It paints a chilling portrait of systemic failure.

Historical and Factual Context

Australia's parole system has been a subject of ongoing debate. The documentary highlights a critical period in Melbourne's history, where the parole system's shortcomings were exposed through these tragic cases.

Key themes in the film

  • Inadequacies of the parole system
  • The cost of systemic failure
  • The impact on victims' families

Film Comparisons

'Murder in Melbourne' shares similarities with documentaries like 'The Central Park Five' and 'Making a Murderer'. However, its focus on the parole system and its impact on a local community sets it apart.

Noteworthy Moments

One of the most striking moments in the documentary is the raw and emotional interviews with the victims' families, conveying the profound grief and anger resulting from these avoidable tragedies.


This documentary has been lauded for its unflinching portrayal of a volatile topic. Reviewers have praised it for shedding light on a critical issue and fostering important discussions about parole system reform.


'Murder in Melbourne' is a must-watch for those interested in criminal justice reform, shedding light on the dire consequences of a failing parole system and the urgent need for change.

More film information:


  • Genre: Documentary



  • Director: Terry Carlyon
  • Victims' Families: Various contributors



  • Melbourne, Australia

Key Questions Raised by the Film:

  • How can the parole system be improved to prevent similar tragedies?
  • What are the impacts on the families and the community?
  • How does the story reflect on broader issues of justice and accountability?

I wonder what the film would be in another art form

Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
  1. If this film was a famous book, which one would it be? 'In Cold Blood' by Truman Capote - because of its detailed examination of a murder case.
  2. If this film was a famous song, which one would it be? 'Behind Blue Eyes' by The Who - due to its theme of hidden pain and sorrow.
  3. If this film was a famous piece of art, which one would it be? 'The Scream' by Edvard Munch - reflecting the anguish and despair depicted in the film.
  4. If this film was a famous celebrity, who would it be? Angelina Jolie - for her advocacy for victims and work on justice reform.
  5. If this film was a color, which one would it be? Grey - representing the somber and grim theme of the film.
  6. If this film was a music style, which one would it be? Blues - as it captures the deep emotional resonance of the film.