Skip to content

Examining the Depths of Childhood Darkness in Playground Murder Plot

Playground Murder Plot is an unsettling exploration of a chilling crime committed by two young boys in a small American town.

Childhood crime, Juvenile justice, True crime documentary, American legal system, Mental health, Small-town America. Three words: Unsettling, Provocative, Eye-opening


"Playground Murder Plot" is a deeply unsettling documentary directed by Zara Hayes and released in 2012. The film delves into a horrific event in the small town of Enchanted Hills, Indiana, where a 12-year-old boy named Paul Gingerich and his 15-year-old friend Colt Lundy shockingly murdered Colt's stepfather.


The documentary chronicles the chilling story of how in April 2010, the two boys cold-bloodedly gunned down Colt's stepfather. The case both baffled and gripped America, stirring debates about childhood crime and the American juvenile justice system.

More Film Analysis


Hayes' approach in "Playground Murder Plot" is meticulously researched and deeply empathetic. The film examines not just the crime itself, but the conditions surrounding it — the small-town setting, the boys' backgrounds, and the intricacies of the American legal system when it comes to juvenile crime.

Historical and Factual Context

In America, juvenile crime has been a contentious issue for decades, with laws and policies varying wildly by state. This context adds an additional layer of complexity to the boys' case, raising questions about responsibility, reform, and justice.

Key themes in the film

  • Childhood crime and its consequences
  • The American juvenile justice system
  • The effects of crime on small-town communities
  • Mental health and crime

Film Comparisons

"Playground Murder Plot" can be compared to other true crime documentaries like "Making a Murderer" and "The Central Park Five", which also grapple with issues of justice, crime, and childhood innocence.

Noteworthy Moments

One of the most shocking moments in the documentary is the revelation of the boys' seemingly calm demeanor after the crime, raising disturbing questions about their mental states.


This documentary was met with mixed reviews, with some viewers finding the subject matter too depressing, while others praised it for its unflinching examination of a difficult topic.


"Playground Murder Plot" is a thought-provoking documentary that will appeal to viewers interested in legal studies, psychology, and true crime. Its exploration of childhood crime and the American juvenile justice system is both heart-wrenching and enlightening.

More film information:


  • IMDB score: 7.1/10
  • Rotten Tomatoes score: 76%
  • Metacritic score: 68
  • Film festival awards: N/A



  • Paul Gingerich: The 12-year-old boy convicted of murder
  • Colt Lundy: The 15-year-old boy who played a key role in the murder



  • Enchanted Hills, Indiana: The small town where the crime took place

Key Questions Raised by the Film:

  • What leads children to commit horrific crimes?
  • How should the legal system deal with juvenile offenders?
  • How does crime affect small-town communities?

I wonder what the film would be in another art form

Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
  1. If this film was a famous book, it would be "Lord of the Flies" because of its exploration of childhood innocence lost to violence.
  2. If this film was a famous song, it would be "Behind Blue Eyes" by The Who, reflecting the hidden darkness in seemingly ordinary lives.
  3. If this film was a famous piece of art, it would be "The Scream" by Edvard Munch, embodying the horror and despair at the heart of the story.
  4. If this film was a famous celebrity, it would be Robert Downey Jr. for his struggle and eventual recovery from personal darkness.
  5. If this film was a color, it would be dark grey, reflecting its somber and disturbing themes.
  6. If this film was a music style, it would be heavy metal because of its raw intensity and dark themes.