Skip to content

The Penalty: A Deep Dive into the Capital Punishment Crisis

The Penalty is a compelling documentary that unearths the complex issues surrounding the death penalty in America through the personal journeys of three unique individuals.

Keywords: capital punishment, botched executions, wrongful convictions, grieving families, justice system, human rights.


"The Penalty" is a riveting documentary directed by Will Francome and Mark Pizzey. Released in 2018, the film embarks on an exploration of the death penalty within the American justice system, focusing on three unique stories of recovery, discovery, and rebellion. Given the ongoing debates around capital punishment, this documentary holds immense relevance in today's discourse on justice, human rights, and penal reforms.


The documentary follows the journeys of three extraordinary individuals who find themselves at the heart of the biggest capital punishment crisis in modern memory. The film exposes a side of America where botched executions, wrongful convictions, and the grieving families left behind prompt us to question our understanding of the death penalty.

More Film Analysis



The documentary adopts an investigative approach, delving deeply into the subject matter through personal stories and comprehensive research. The filmmakers have intricately explored the depth of the subject, presenting a compelling narrative that leaves a lasting impact on the viewer.

Historical and Factual Context


"The Penalty" is set against the backdrop of the ongoing debate around the death penalty in America. With the first recorded execution dating back to 1608, capital punishment has been a contentious issue within the U.S. justice system, with various states adopting different stances on the matter.

Key themes in the film

  • The fallibility of justice: The documentary highlights instances of wrongful convictions, questioning the infallibility of the justice system.
  • Human rights: By showcasing botched executions, the film raises questions about the humane nature of capital punishment.
  • The grief of families: The film explores the emotional turmoil experienced by the families of the convicts, adding a deeply personal perspective to the debate.

Film Comparisons

Unlike other documentaries on iWonder that focus on wrongful convictions, "The Penalty" delves into the broader issue of capital punishment, examining its many dimensions.

Noteworthy Moments

The most significant moments in the documentary include the revelation of botched executions and the emotional narratives of grieving families that challenge viewers' perceptions of the death penalty.


While there isn't much information available on audience and critic reception, the documentary's exploration of a sensitive issue like the death penalty is sure to spark thoughtful discussion and reflection.


"The Penalty" adds a significant contribution to the discourse on capital punishment through its personal narratives and deep exploration of the subject. It is a must-watch for anyone interested in human rights, law, and societal issues.

More film information:


  • Genre: Documentary



  • Will Francome: Director
  • Mark Pizzey: Director



  • United States

Key Questions Raised by the Film

  1. Is the death penalty a just form of punishment?
  2. How does the grief of families influence the discourse on capital punishment?
  3. What are the implications of wrongful convictions in the context of the death penalty?

I wonder what the film would be in another art form

Image 1
Image 2
Image 3
  1. A famous book, it would be "Dead Man Walking" - both explore the controversies and emotional turmoil surrounding the death penalty.
  2. A famous song, it would be "Hurricane" by Bob Dylan - a song about injustice and wrongful conviction.
  3. A famous piece of art, it would be Picasso's "Guernica" - both depict the anguish and suffering caused by violence.
  4. A famous celebrity, it would be Bryan Stevenson - a lawyer known for his work on wrongful convictions and the death penalty.
  5. A colour, it would be grey - symbolising the moral ambiguity and complexity of the issue.
  6. A music style, it would be blues - representing the grief and struggle depicted in the film.